20-40% Off All Shirts, Hats And Bags
ImageOur groovy shirts, bags and caps are just so good, we had to share em! Get one before they are all gone!
 
Home arrow Forum arrow Fascinating RAW Facts! arrow RAW Facts, Info and Science arrow Maple Syrup - Raw? I Don't Think So!
Maple Syrup - Raw? I Don't Think So!
   ..Home   ..Help ..Login ..Register  
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. « previous next »
Pages: [1] Go Down Print
Author Topic: Maple Syrup - Raw? I Don't Think So!  (Read 708 times)
Sheryl
Administrator
Leader
*****

Karma: 135
Offline Offline

Posts: 4342




View Profile
« on: Tuesday 30 November, 2004 »

Maple syrup is something that is definitely highly cooked, but many raw people still use it (ie Juliano). We've even talked to some people that say they do it to support the trees!

In the old days maple syrup was cooked outside in large vats over wood fires. Not anymore!

Many growers use formaldehyde to keep the tap holes in the tree from healing, and use lead soldered buckets. Sap is often boiled over oil burners, filtered, with antifoaming agents and polishing agents to "improve" the end product. Even worse for vegetarians and vegans, animal fats are often added as an antifoaming agent, making maple syrup both cooked and a non-vegetarian product.

There are obviously still some old fashioned producers out there. If you choose to use maple syrup make sure you know your source.

I've also heard from some that they have been able to access raw unfiltered maple sap.  That could be an interesting `option` for adding liquids to raw treats! If anyone knows of ways to use maple sap we'd love to hear!

The details above on maple syrup production are from a fabulous new book called "Unsafe at any Meal: How to Avoid Hidden Toxins in Your Food" by Dr Earl Mindell's.  

For vegans and vegetarians looking for an alternative pleasure you may choose to use raw agave nectar or raw honey instead.

Cheers,
Sheryl
Report to moderator   Logged

hikergirl
Blossom
****

Karma: 7
Offline Offline

Posts: 67


View Profile
« Reply #1 on: Saturday 09 December, 2006 »

Raw friends,

I live in a sugarbush (that's a wooded area with many or mostly sugar maple trees) in Vermont (USA). We have a very small sugarbush (50 acres). We have neighbors that have hundreds of acres. We make maple syrup.

While maple syrup IS boiled, it does not and cannot have additives in it or preservatives without ruining the flavor. Maple syrup is very finicky! It's hard to make and easy to ruin. Here is how it is made:

A small, shallow hole is drilled in the side of a mature tree and a hollow plug is inserted into the hole. A bucket is then hung on the tree or tubing is connected between the trees. Tubing is not very common because it is expensive and very difficult to reuse. The tried and true method (walking through the woods to empty the buckets of sap by hand into a huge barrel) is still the standard. There is an old saying, "Time stands still in the sugarbush." This is true. Horses are still used to pull the sledges through the woods because no motorized vehicles could maneuver through the snow between the trees.

I guarantee that there are NO maple syrup producers in the whole country who will put a chemical of any kind on the holes in the trees. There is no need to do it! At the end of the sap run, which usually lasts about 2 - 3 weeks, the small plugs are removed and the trees naturally heal up the tiny hole. A new hole is drilled in a different place the following year. You can't use the same hole twice - ever. And you wouldn't want to - it would scar the tree and sap wouldn't come out of that hole.

Daily, because raw sap won't last more than a day without spoiling, the sap is boiled down over a wood fire - no other fuel can be used or the fire won't be the right temperature. The raw sap looks like water and if you taste it you get only a faintly sweet hint of maple flavor.

For every 40 gallons of sap you boil down, you get 1 gallon of maple syrup. The fire has to be monitored constantly to avoid a boil-over or a burn. In an evaporator pan, if the syrup maker is not experienced enough to monitor the fire properly, the sap can get too hot and threaten to boil-over. Then the fastest way to calm the bubbling syrup is to put a drop (one single drop!) of butter or cream on the pan. That's one drop per dozens of gallons of syrup that foams at the top of the syrup and gets skimmed off! (And this is a Newbie mistake that no experienced sugar maker would make!) NO chemicals can be added or the syrup would be ruined!

This can take 14-16 hours a day on a good day. So, you see how labor-intensive the syrup-making a process is. There is more to it - filtering through a wool felt funnel to remove any twigs or leaves or anything that might have fallen into the bucket, testing the density with a hygrometer (looks like a fat glass thermometer) and grading the syrup by color. But that is how you make syrup. There is no other way. There are no chemicals. There are no addititives. There is NO CHOICE!

So, if you do like maple syrup, you can eat it without worry. And I am not saying this for any gain on my part - we don't sell our syrup, we just make enough for our family and some friends and relatives. But I promise - syrup is safe and clean. If you DO want to eat it - ENJOY IT!
Report to moderator   Logged
hikergirl
Blossom
****

Karma: 7
Offline Offline

Posts: 67


View Profile
« Reply #2 on: Saturday 09 December, 2006 »

I forgot to tell you - the buckets are NOT lead soldered! They are either oaken or tin or stainless steel. Sugarmakers would not use lead soldered buckets!!! They naver have and never will!
Report to moderator   Logged
Sheryl
Administrator
Leader
*****

Karma: 135
Offline Offline

Posts: 4342




View Profile
« Reply #3 on: Saturday 09 December, 2006 »

Thanks Hikergirl. That makes sense! I pulled that off a website on maple syrup and now that you mention it when I've seen it in Canada it's as you described too. I can believe that plastic tubing wouldn't work too well.. just imagine the maintenance keeping them clean and free flowing.

When I was little we made maple syrup a couple of times... what a fun process. Only once inside the house.. what a mess. After that outside. Maple sap flow coincided with March break, which was perfect!!

Cheers,
Sheryl
Report to moderator   Logged

Sheryl
Administrator
Leader
*****

Karma: 135
Offline Offline

Posts: 4342




View Profile
« Reply #4 on: Saturday 09 December, 2006 »

Hikergirl. I was curious and did a little research.. apparently some of these things were common in past and are still used by people that haven't updated their methods...

http://www.umext.maine.edu/onlinepubs/htmpubs/7038.htm
"Warning: Don’t use paraformaldehyde pellets. In the past, paraformaldehyde pellets were recommended for use in tap holes; some out-of-date sugaring manuals still suggest their use. Research shows that the use of paraformaldehyde pellets can damage the trees, so they are now illegal. Similarly, the use of denatured alcohol as a disinfectant for tapholes is also illegal in Maine."

Syrup recalls due to lead contamination: http://www.inspection.gc.ca/english/corpaffr/recarapp/2004/20040507e.shtml

And here's an Ontario Government publication about reducing lead in maple syrup:
http://www.omafra.gov.on.ca/english/crops/facts/ms_lead.htm

So what it looks like to me is that there are best practices, and then there are good meaning people using equipment that's been used for years that appears to be in good working order, which may have been manufactured before materials were changed over (mid 90's for most of them). I know from looking at the photos in the last link that the ones I grew up using were the ones indicated as now considered dangerous (not stainless steel) and would therefore have contributed lead to our maple syrup.

Like with many things, knowing your grower is a great way to make sure you are consuming high grade foods! I'm not meaning to be argumentative in any way here... I was just wondering if it really was the case that none of this was true where I found it.

Cheers,
Sheryl

Report to moderator   Logged

durianrider
God of Cacao
Leader
******

Karma: 122
Offline Offline

Posts: 3894



june 2008, where is your head at?


View Profile
« Reply #5 on: Saturday 09 December, 2006 »

looks like we have both side of the coin here..

ive eaten a few recipies with a dash of maple syrup in it. im cool with that as long as its organic maple. ive had maybe 2 tablespoons this year.

ive visited a lot of non organic farms in my travels. and havent been impressed with what ive seen. i have more faith in organic. seeing the dudes walking around in space suits with masks and spraying monsanto juice around the place...nothing suprises me now when it comes to commercial foods. from feeding cement dust to cows, to putting chicken feathers into bread, or using hexanes to produce cooked chocolate...some people will do anything to make a buck..

rather than  panic, just go organic.
« Last Edit: Saturday 09 December, 2006 by durianrider » Report to moderator   Logged

100% RAW! count on it!
http://www.myspace.com/durianrider
Pages: [1] Go Up Print 
« previous next »
Jump to:  
Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.2 | SMF © 2006-2007, Simple Machines LLC Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!

Featured Resource

Cacao Beans (Raw, Organic, Vegan) 500g

These cacao beans are of the highest quality Criollo variety. They have a rich, chocolaty flavour that is present with out any heat treatment. These delicious raw beans are whole and peeled.
[Click Here to Learn More...]
$45.00 (inc GST)
$35.00 (inc GST)
You Save: $10.00
Average customer rating
5 stars Total votes: 2
All content and rights reserved and © 2005 - 2006 Raw Pleasure Pty Ltd.
Content written by third parties on this site solely represent their own opinions and not necessarily those of Raw Pleasure Pty Ltd.
If you are not willing to take personal responsibility for your own health, and feel you need medical/dental advice, then visit a doctor/dentist.
The contents of this site of an educational nature only and are not medical / dental advice.
Nothing here is intended to diagnose, treat, prevent or cure any medical condition.
email